| Round 1 | ||||
| Best One | 1 | Adrian Peterson | RB | Vikings |
| The Pack Is Back | 2 | Aaron Rodgers | QB | Packers |
| Head And Broken Shoulder | 3 | Drew Brees | QB | Saints |
| Let's Get Ready To Fumble | 4 | Tom Brady | QB | Patriots |
| Pam And Da Boyz | 5 | Ray Rice | RB | Ravens |
| Jacquizz In My Pants | 6 | Rashard Mendenhall | RB | Steelers |
| The Ick Shuffle | 7 | Michael Vick | QB | Eagles |
| Mannings Crossing | 8 | Michael Turner | RB | Falcons |
| Hightowered Offense | 9 | Philip Rivers | QB | Chargers |
| Tressel's Innocent | 10 | Tony Romo | QB | Cowboys |
| Clear My Bironas | 11 | Chris Johnson | RB | Titans |
| Footsie With Rex | 12 | Arian Foster | RB | Texans |
| Schweddy Balls | 13 | Peyton Hillis | RB | Browns |
| Repeat? Yes, Yes, Yes | 14 | Matt Schaub | QB | Texans |
| Round 2 | ||||
| Repeat? Yes, Yes, Yes | 15 | Maurice Jones-Drew | RB | Jaguars |
| Schweddy Balls | 16 | LeSean McCoy | RB | Eagles |
| Footsie With Rex | 17 | Mike Tolbert | RB | Chargers |
| Clear My Bironas | 18 | BenJarvus Green-Ellis | RB | Patriots |
| Tressel's Innocent | 19 | Matt Ryan | QB | Falcons |
| Hightowered Offense | 20 | Tim Hightower | RB | Redskins |
| Mannings Crossing | 21 | Eli Manning | QB | Giants |
| The Ick Shuffle | 22 | Darren McFadden | RB | Raiders |
| Jacquizz In My Pants | 23 | Ahmad Bradshaw | RB | Giants |
| Pam And Da Boyz | 24 | LeGarrette Blount | RB | Buccaneers |
| Let's Get Ready To Fumble | 25 | Frank Gore | RB | 49ers |
| Head And Broken Shoulder | 26 | Jamaal Charles | RB | Chiefs |
| The Pack Is Back | 27 | Steven Jackson | RB | Rams |
| Best One | 28 | Andre Johnson | WR | Texans |
| Round 3 | ||||
| Best One | 29 | Ben Roethlisberger | QB | Steelers |
| The Pack Is Back | 30 | Matthew Stafford | QB | Lions |
| Head And Broken Shoulder | 31 | Jay Cutler | QB | Bears |
| Let's Get Ready To Fumble | 32 | Roddy White | WR | Falcons |
| Pam And Da Boyz | 33 | Josh Freeman | QB | Buccaneers |
| Jacquizz In My Pants | 34 | Joe Flacco | QB | Ravens |
| The Ick Shuffle | 35 | Hakeem Nicks | WR | Giants |
| Mannings Crossing | 36 | Sam Bradford | QB | Rams |
| Hightowered Offense | 37 | Antonio Gates | TE | Chargers |
| Tressel's Innocent | 38 | Jahvid Best | RB | Lions |
| Clear My Bironas | 39 | Matt Cassel | QB | Chiefs |
| Footsie With Rex | 40 | Kevin Kolb | QB | Cardinals |
| Schweddy Balls | 41 | Ryan Fitzpatrick | QB | Bills |
| Repeat? Yes, Yes, Yes | 42 | Knowshon Moreno | RB | Broncos |
| Round 4 | ||||
| Repeat? Yes, Yes, Yes | 43 | Colt McCoy | QB | Browns |
| Schweddy Balls | 44 | Kerry Collins | QB | Colts |
| Footsie With Rex | 45 | Kyle Orton | QB | Broncos |
| Clear My Bironas | 46 | Dwayne Bowe | WR | Chiefs |
| Tressel's Innocent | 47 | Felix Jones | RB | Cowboys |
| Hightowered Offense | 48 | Mark Sanchez | QB | Jets |
| Mannings Crossing | 49 | Willis McGahee | RB | Broncos |
| The Ick Shuffle | 50 | Mark Ingram | RB | Saints |
| Jacquizz In My Pants | 51 | Ryan Mathews | RB | Chargers |
| Pam And Da Boyz | 52 | Calvin Johnson | WR | Lions |
| Let's Get Ready To Fumble | 53 | Greg Jennings | WR | Packers |
| Head And Broken Shoulder | 54 | Brandon Marshall | WR | Dolphins |
| The Pack Is Back | 55 | Nate Kaeding | K | Chargers |
| Best One | 56 | Matt Forte | RB | Bears |
| Round 5 | ||||
| Best One | 57 | Steve Gostkowski | K | Patriots |
| The Pack Is Back | 58 | Neil Rackers | K | Texans |
| Head And Broken Shoulder | 59 | Vincent Jackson | WR | Chargers |
| Let's Get Ready To Fumble | 60 | Beanie Wells | RB | Cardinals |
| Pam And Da Boyz | 61 | Matt Bryant | K | Falcons |
| Jacquizz In My Pants | 62 | John Kasay | K | Saints |
| The Ick Shuffle | 63 | Larry Fitzgerald | WR | Cardinals |
| Mannings Crossing | 64 | Mason Crosby | K | Packers |
| Hightowered Offense | 65 | Brandon Jacobs | RB | Giants |
| Tressel's Innocent | 66 | Alex Henery | K | Eagles |
| Clear My Bironas | 67 | DeSean Jackson | WR | Eagles |
| Footsie With Rex | 68 | Sebby Janikowski | K | Raiders |
| Schweddy Balls | 69 | Shonn Greene | RB | Jets |
| Repeat? Yes, Yes, Yes | 70 | Josh Brown | K | Rams |
| Round 6 | ||||
| Repeat? Yes, Yes, Yes | 71 | Bill Cundiff | K | Ravens |
| Schweddy Balls | 72 | Mike Williams | WR | Buccaneers |
| Footsie With Rex | 73 | Jay Feely | K | Cardinals |
| Clear My Bironas | 74 | Cedric Benson | RB | Bengals |
| Tressel's Innocent | 75 | Robbie Gould | K | Bears |
| Hightowered Offense | 76 | Mike Wallace | WR | Steelers |
| Mannings Crossing | 77 | Rob Bironas | K | Titans |
| The Ick Shuffle | 78 | Nick Folk | K | Jets |
| Jacquizz In My Pants | 79 | David Akers | K | 49ers |
| Pam And Da Boyz | 80 | Santonio Holmes | WR | Jets |
| Let's Get Ready To Fumble | 81 | Dez Bryant | WR | Cowboys |
| Head And Broken Shoulder | 82 | Fred Jackson | RB | Bills |
| The Pack Is Back | 83 | DeAngelo Williams | RB | Panthers |
| Best One | 84 | Jason Campbell | QB | Raiders |
| Round 7 | ||||
| Best One | 85 | Shaun Suisham | K | Steelers |
| The Pack Is Back | 86 | James Starks | RB | Packers |
| Head And Broken Shoulder | 87 | Daniel Thomas | RB | Dolphins |
| Let's Get Ready To Fumble | 88 | Ryan Longwell | K | Vikings |
| Pam And Da Boyz | 89 | Cam Newton | QB | Panthers |
| Jacquizz In My Pants | 90 | Miles Austin | WR | Cowboys |
| The Ick Shuffle | 91 | Joseph Addai | RB | Colts |
| Mannings Crossing | 92 | Vernon Davis | TE | 49ers |
| Hightowered Offense | 93 | Jason Hanson | K | Lions |
| Tressel's Innocent | 94 | Steve Johnson | WR | Bills |
| Clear My Bironas | 95 | Percy Harvin | WR | Vikings |
| Footsie With Rex | 96 | Darren Sproles | RB | Saints |
| Schweddy Balls | 97 | Julio Jones | WR | Falcons |
| Repeat? Yes, Yes, Yes | 98 | Brandon Lloyd | WR | Broncos |
| Round 8 | ||||
| Repeat? Yes, Yes, Yes | 99 | Jeremy Maclin | WR | Eagles |
| Schweddy Balls | 100 | Robert Meachem | WR | Saints |
| Footsie With Rex | 101 | Jacoby Ford | WR | Raiders |
| Clear My Bironas | 102 | Donovan McNabb | QB | Vikings |
| Tressel's Innocent | 103 | Randall Cobb | WR | Packers |
| Hightowered Offense | 104 | Mario Manningham | WR | Giants |
| Mannings Crossing | 105 | Kenny Britt | WR | Titans |
| The Ick Shuffle | 106 | Jason Witten | TE | Cowboys |
| Jacquizz In My Pants | 107 | Jermichael Finley | TE | Packers |
| Pam And Da Boyz | 108 | Wes Welker | WR | Patriots |
| Let's Get Ready To Fumble | 109 | Reggie Wayne | WR | Colts |
| Head And Broken Shoulder | 110 | Adam Vinatieri | K | Colts |
| The Pack Is Back | 111 | Jordy Nelson | WR | Packers |
| Best One | 112 | Anquan Boldin | WR | Ravens |
| Round 9 | ||||
| Best One | 113 | Reggie Bush | WR | Dolphins |
| The Pack Is Back | 114 | Chad Ochocinco | WR | Patriots |
| Head And Broken Shoulder | 115 | Hines Ward | WR | Steelers |
| Let's Get Ready To Fumble | 116 | Ryan Succop | K | Chiefs |
| Pam And Da Boyz | 117 | Ryan Grant | RB | Packers |
| Jacquizz In My Pants | 118 | Malcolm Floyd | WR | Chargers |
| The Ick Shuffle | 119 | Matt Prater | K | Broncos |
| Mannings Crossing | 120 | Owen Daniels | TE | Texans |
| Hightowered Offense | 121 | Jimmy Graham | TE | Saints |
| Tressel's Innocent | 122 | Marshawn Lynch | RB | Seahawks |
| Clear My Bironas | 123 | Dan Carpenter | K | Dolphins |
| Footsie With Rex | 124 | Braylon Edwards | WR | 49ers |
| Schweddy Balls | 125 | Green Bay | TM | Packers |
| Repeat? Yes, Yes, Yes | 126 | John Kuhn | RB | Packers |
| Round 10 | ||||
| Repeat? Yes, Yes, Yes | 127 | Dallas Clark | TE | Colts |
| Schweddy Balls | 128 | Dan Bailey | K | Cowboys |
| Footsie With Rex | 129 | Devin Hester | WR | Bears |
| Clear My Bironas | 130 | Connor Barth | K | Buccaneers |
| Tressel's Innocent | 131 | Lee Evans | WR | Ravens |
| Hightowered Offense | 132 | New Orleans | TM | Saints |
| Mannings Crossing | 133 | Devery Henderson | WR | Saints |
| The Ick Shuffle | 134 | Philadelphia | TM | Eagles |
| Jacquizz In My Pants | 135 | New York | TM | Jets |
| Pam And Da Boyz | 136 | Lawrence Tynes | K | Giants |
| Let's Get Ready To Fumble | 137 | LaDainian Tomlinson | RB | Jets |
| Head And Broken Shoulder | 138 | Roy Williams | WR | Bears |
| The Pack Is Back | 139 | Plaxico Burress | WR | Jets |
| Best One | 140 | Michael Crabtree | WR | 49ers |
| Round 11 | ||||
| Best One | 141 | Pittsburgh | TM | Steelers |
| The Pack Is Back | 142 | Baltimore | TM | Ravens |
| Head And Broken Shoulder | 143 | Chicago | TM | Bears |
| Let's Get Ready To Fumble | 144 | Alex Smith | QB | 49ers |
| Pam And Da Boyz | 145 | Santana Moss | WR | Redskins |
| Jacquizz In My Pants | 146 | Mike Sims-Walker | WR | Rams |
| The Ick Shuffle | 147 | Lance Kendricks | TE | Rams |
| Mannings Crossing | 148 | Jonathan Stewart | RB | Panthers |
| Hightowered Offense | 149 | Phil Dawson | K | Browns |
| Tressel's Innocent | 150 | New England | TM | Patriots |
| Clear My Bironas | 151 | Arizona | TM | Cardinals |
| Footsie With Rex | 152 | Dallas | TM | Cowboys |
| Schweddy Balls | 153 | Danny Amendola | WR | Rams |
| Repeat? Yes, Yes, Yes | 154 | Atlanta | TM | Falcons |
| Round 12 | ||||
| Repeat? Yes, Yes, Yes | 155 | A.J. Green | WR | Bengals |
| Schweddy Balls | 156 | Rian Lindell | K | Bills |
| Footsie With Rex | 157 | Tony Gonzalez | TE | Falcons |
| Clear My Bironas | 158 | Rob Gronkowski | TE | Patriots |
| Tressel's Innocent | 159 | Deion Branch | WR | Patriots |
| Hightowered Offense | 160 | Michael Bush | RB | Raiders |
| Mannings Crossing | 161 | San Francisco | TM | 49ers |
| The Ick Shuffle | 162 | Matt Hasselbeck | QB | Titans |
| Jacquizz In My Pants | 163 | Chad Henne | QB | Dolphins |
| Pam And Da Boyz | 164 | Detroit | TM | Lions |
| Let's Get Ready To Fumble | 165 | New York | TM | Giants |
| Head And Broken Shoulder | 166 | Olindo Mare | K | Panthers |
| The Pack Is Back | 167 | Johnny Knox | WR | Bears |
| Best One | 168 | Steve Smith | WR | Panthers |
