| Round 1 | ||||
| The Haves And The Havlats | 1 | Henrik Lundqvist | G | Rangers |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 2 | Alex Ovechkin | F | Capitals |
| Czech Out Lines | 3 | Ryan Miller | G | Sabres |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 4 | Roberto Luongo | G | Canucks |
| Chicken Parm | 5 | Jimmy Howard | G | Red Wings |
| Laraque The Casbah | 6 | Ilya Bryzgalov | G | Flyers |
| Lady Bada Byng | 7 | Marc-Andre Fleury | G | Penguins |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 8 | Steve Stamkos | F | Lightning |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 9 | Henrik Sedin | F | Canucks |
| Phantom Up | 10 | Tim Thomas | G | Bruins |
| Foil Up Coach | 11 | Tomas Vokoun | G | Capitals |
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 12 | Miikka Kiprusoff | G | Flames |
| Round 2 | ||||
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 13 | Daniel Sedin | F | Canucks |
| Foil Up Coach | 14 | Pekka Rinne | G | Predators |
| Phantom Up | 15 | Corey Perry | F | Ducks |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 16 | Corey Crawford | G | Blackhawks |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 17 | Antti Niemi | G | Sharks |
| Lady Bada Byng | 18 | Jonas Hiller | G | Ducks |
| Laraque The Casbah | 19 | Martin Brodeur | G | Devils |
| Chicken Parm | 20 | Jonathan Quick | G | Kings |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 21 | Carey Price | G | Canadiens |
| Czech Out Lines | 22 | Evgeni Malkin | F | Penguins |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 23 | Cam Ward | G | Hurricanes |
| The Haves And The Havlats | 24 | Jaroslav Halak | G | Blues |
| Round 3 | ||||
| The Haves And The Havlats | 25 | Anze Kopitar | F | Kings |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 26 | Dwayne Roloson | G | Lightning |
| Czech Out Lines | 27 | Kari Lehtonen | G | Stars |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 28 | Sidney Crosby | F | Penguins |
| Chicken Parm | 29 | Martin St. Louis | F | Lightning |
| Laraque The Casbah | 30 | Nicklas Backstrom | F | Capitals |
| Lady Bada Byng | 31 | Ilya Kovalchuk | F | Devils |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 32 | Zach Parise | F | Devils |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 33 | Ryan Getzlaf | F | Ducks |
| Phantom Up | 34 | Pavel Datsyuk | F | Red Wings |
| Foil Up Coach | 35 | Claude Giroux | F | Flyers |
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 36 | James Reimer | G | Maple Leafs |
| Round 4 | ||||
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 37 | Joe Thornton | F | Sharks |
| Foil Up Coach | 38 | Jonathan Toews | F | Blackhawks |
| Phantom Up | 39 | Jarome Iginla | F | Flames |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 40 | Steve Mason | G | Blue Jackets |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 41 | Alexander Semin | F | Capitals |
| Lady Bada Byng | 42 | Rick Nash | F | Blue Jackets |
| Laraque The Casbah | 43 | Drew Doughty | D | Kings |
| Chicken Parm | 44 | Eric Staal | F | Hurricanes |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 45 | Niklas Backstrom | G | Wild |
| Czech Out Lines | 46 | Bobby Ryan | F | Ducks |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 47 | Dustin Byfuglien | D | Jets |
| The Haves And The Havlats | 48 | Brad Richards | F | Rangers |
| Round 5 | ||||
| The Haves And The Havlats | 49 | Zdeno Chara | D | Bruins |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 50 | Mike Richards | F | Kings |
| Czech Out Lines | 51 | Danny Briere | F | Flyers |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 52 | Jeff Carter | F | Blue Jackets |
| Chicken Parm | 53 | Mike Green | D | Capitals |
| Laraque The Casbah | 54 | Steve Downie | F | Lightning |
| Lady Bada Byng | 55 | Henrik Zetterberg | F | Red Wings |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 56 | Kris Letang | D | Penguins |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 57 | Lubomir Visnovsky | D | Ducks |
| Phantom Up | 58 | Alexander Burrows | F | Canucks |
| Foil Up Coach | 59 | Dan Boyle | D | Sharks |
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 60 | Matt Duchene | F | Avalanche |
| Round 6 | ||||
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 61 | Christian Ehrhoff | D | Canuck |
| Foil Up Coach | 62 | Milan Lucic | F | Bruins |
| Phantom Up | 63 | Phil Kessel | F | Maple Leafs |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 64 | John Tavares | F | Islanders |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 65 | Patrick Marleau | F | Sharks |
| Lady Bada Byng | 66 | Patrick Kane | F | Blackhawks |
| Laraque The Casbah | 67 | Dany Heatley | F | Wild |
| Chicken Parm | 68 | P.K. Subban | D | Canadiens |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 69 | David Backes | F | Blues |
| Czech Out Lines | 70 | Ryane Clowe | F | Sharks |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 71 | Ryan Kesler | F | Canucks |
| The Haves And The Havlats | 72 | Patrick Sharp | F | Blackhawks |
| Round 7 | ||||
| The Haves And The Havlats | 73 | Duncan Keith | D | Blackhawks |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 74 | Keith Yandle | D | Coyotes |
| Czech Out Lines | 75 | Thomas Vanek | F | Sabres |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 76 | Shea Weber | D | Predators |
| Chicken Parm | 77 | Jaromir Jagr | F | Flyers |
| Laraque The Casbah | 78 | Marian Gaborik | F | Rangers |
| Lady Bada Byng | 79 | Kevin Bieksa | D | Canucks |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 80 | Derek Roy | F | Sabres |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 81 | Nicklas Lidstrom | D | Red Wings |
| Phantom Up | 82 | Joe Pavelski | F | Sharks |
| Foil Up Coach | 83 | Chris Stewart | F | Blues |
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 84 | James Neal | F | Penguins |
| Round 8 | ||||
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 85 | Brayden Schenn | F | Flyers |
| Foil Up Coach | 86 | Alexander Edler | D | Canucks |
| Phantom Up | 87 | Craig Anderson | G | Senators |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 88 | Mark Streit | D | Islanders |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 89 | Ondrej Pavelec | G | Jets |
| Lady Bada Byng | 90 | Brent Burns | D | Sharks |
| Laraque The Casbah | 91 | Logan Couture | F | Sharks |
| Chicken Parm | 92 | Johan Franzen | F | Red Wings |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 93 | Marian Hossa | F | Blackhawks |
| Czech Out Lines | 94 | Semyon Varlamov | G | Avalanche |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 95 | Nathan Horton | F | Bruins |
| The Haves And The Havlats | 96 | Martin Havlat | F | Sharks |
| Round 9 | ||||
| The Haves And The Havlats | 97 | Vincent Lecavalier | F | Lightning |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 98 | Scott Hartnell | F | Flyers |
| Czech Out Lines | 99 | Dustin Brown | F | Kings |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 100 | Dion Phaneuf | D | Maple Leafs |
| Chicken Parm | 101 | Matt Cooke | F | Penguins |
| Laraque The Casbah | 102 | Mike Smith | G | Coyotes |
| Lady Bada Byng | 103 | Tuukka Rask | G | Bruins |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 104 | David Krejci | F | Bruins |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 105 | Alex Goligoski | D | Stars |
| Phantom Up | 106 | John Carlson | D | Capitals |
| Foil Up Coach | 107 | Taylor Hall | F | Oilers |
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 108 | Jeff Skinner | F | Hurricanes |
| Round 10 | ||||
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 109 | James Wisniewski | D | Blue Jackets |
| Foil Up Coach | 110 | James van Riemsdyk | F | Flyers |
| Phantom Up | 111 | Jason Spezza | F | Senators |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 112 | Jason Pominville | F | Sabres |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 113 | Patrik Elias | F | Devils |
| Lady Bada Byng | 114 | Ryan Suter | D | Predators |
| Laraque The Casbah | 115 | Tomas Plekanec | F | Canadiens |
| Chicken Parm | 116 | Dustin Penner | F | Kings |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 117 | Mikko Koivu | F | Wild |
| Czech Out Lines | 118 | Paul Stastny | F | Avalanche |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 119 | Andy McDonald | F | Blues |
| The Haves And The Havlats | 120 | Mike Cammalleri | F | Canadiens |
| Round 11 | ||||
| The Haves And The Havlats | 121 | Ryan Callahan | F | Rangers |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 122 | Brandon Dubinsky | F | Rangers |
| Czech Out Lines | 123 | Alex Tanguay | F | Flames |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 124 | Chris Pronger | D | Flyers |
| Chicken Parm | 125 | Tobias Enstrom | D | Jets |
| Laraque The Casbah | 126 | Adam Larsson | D | Devils |
| Lady Bada Byng | 127 | Teemu Selanne | F | Ducks |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 128 | Andrew Ladd | F | Jets |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 129 | Tomas Kaberle | D | Bruins |
| Phantom Up | 130 | Travis Hamonic | D | Islanders |
| Foil Up Coach | 131 | Tyler Myers | D | Sabres |
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 132 | Devon Setoguchi | F | Wild |
| Round 12 | ||||
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 133 | R.J. Umberger | F | Blue Jackets |
| Foil Up Coach | 134 | Alex Pietrangelo | D | Blues |
| Phantom Up | 135 | Roman Hamrlik | D | Capitals |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 136 | Erik Johnson | D | Avalanche |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 137 | Loui Eriksson | F | Stars |
| Lady Bada Byng | 138 | Niklas Kronwall | D | Red Wings |
| Laraque The Casbah | 139 | Zenon Konopka | F | Senators |
| Chicken Parm | 140 | Chris Neil | F | Senators |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 141 | Gabriel Landeskog | F | Avalanche |
| Czech Out Lines | 142 | Mike Ribeiro | F | Stars |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 143 | Ryan Whitney | D | Oilers |
| The Haves And The Havlats | 144 | Cory Schneider | G | Canucks |
| Round 13 | ||||
| The Haves And The Havlats | 145 | Wayne Simmonds | F | Flyers |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 146 | Jonathan Bernier | G | Kings |
| Czech Out Lines | 147 | Mark Giordano | D | Flames |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 148 | Michael Grabner | F | Islanders |
| Chicken Parm | 149 | Jose Theodore | G | Panthers |
| Laraque The Casbah | 150 | Erik Karlsson | D | Senators |
| Lady Bada Byng | 151 | Brenden Morrow | F | Stars |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 152 | Brent Seabrook | D | Blackhawks |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 153 | Steve Ott | F | Stars |
| Phantom Up | 154 | Michal Neuvirth | G | Capitals |
| Foil Up Coach | 155 | Patrice Bergeron | F | Bruins |
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 156 | Sergei Bobrovsky | G | Flyers |
| Round 14 | ||||
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 157 | Joni Pitkanen | F | Hurricanes |
| Foil Up Coach | 158 | Brian Campbell | D | Panthers |
| Phantom Up | 159 | Jordan Staal | F | Penguins |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 160 | Luke Adam | F | Sabres |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 161 | Kevin Shattenkirk | D | Blues |
| Lady Bada Byng | 162 | Brian Gionta | F | Canadiens |
| Laraque The Casbah | 163 | Matt Carle | D | Flyers |
| Chicken Parm | 164 | Sergei Gonchar | D | Senators |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 165 | Chris Kunitz | F | Penguins |
| Czech Out Lines | 166 | Victor Hedman | D | Lightning |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 167 | Shane Doan | F | Coyotes |
| The Haves And The Havlats | 168 | Theo Peckham | D | Oilers |
| Round 15 | ||||
| The Haves And The Havlats | 169 | Dan Hamhuis | D | Canucks |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 170 | John-Michael Liles | D | Maple Leafs |
| Czech Out Lines | 171 | Jamie McBain | D | Hurricanes |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 172 | Marek Zidlicky | D | Wild |
| Chicken Parm | 173 | Kimmo Timonen | D | Flyers |
| Laraque The Casbah | 174 | Ales Hemsky | F | Oilers |
| Lady Bada Byng | 175 | Cam Fowler | D | Ducks |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 176 | Anton Babchuk | D | Hurricanes |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 177 | Matt Moulson | F | Islanders |
| Phantom Up | 178 | Sheldon Souray | D | Stars |
| Foil Up Coach | 179 | Anders Lindback | G | Predators |
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 180 | Erik Johnson | D | Avalanche |
| Round 16 | ||||
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 181 | Clarke MacArthur | F | Maple Leafs |
| Foil Up Coach | 182 | Brooks Laich | F | Capitals |
| Phantom Up | 183 | Adam McQuaid | D | Bruins |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 184 | George Parros | F | Ducks |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 185 | Al Montoya | G | Islanders |
| Lady Bada Byng | 186 | Ian White | D | Red Wings |
| Laraque The Casbah | 187 | Marc-Andre Bergeron | D | Lightning |
| Chicken Parm | 188 | Teddy Purcell | F | Lightning |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 189 | Brad Boyes | F | Sabres |
| Czech Out Lines | 190 | Andrej Meszaros | D | Flyers |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 191 | Brandon Prust | F | Rangers |
| The Haves And The Havlats | 192 | Steve Montador | D | Blackhawks |
| Round 17 | ||||
| The Haves And The Havlats | 193 | Jonathon Blum | D | Predators |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 194 | Grant Clitsome | D | Blue Jackets |
| Czech Out Lines | 195 | Dennis Seidenberg | D | Bruins |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 196 | Jay Bouwmeester | D | Flames |
| Chicken Parm | 197 | Shane O'Brien | D | Avalanche |
| Laraque The Casbah | 198 | T.J. Oshie | F | Blues |
| Lady Bada Byng | 199 | Drew Stafford | F | Sabres |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 200 | Paul Martin | D | Penguins |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 201 | Trevor Gillies | F | Islanders |
| Phantom Up | 202 | Dennis Wideman | D | Capitals |
| Foil Up Coach | 203 | Ville Leino | F | Sabres |
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 204 | Joe Corvo | D | Bruins |
| Round 18 | ||||
| Commish For Pres 2012 | 205 | Jason Demers | D | Sharks |
| Foil Up Coach | 206 | Andrei Markov | D | Canadiens |
| Phantom Up | 207 | Steve Sullivan | F | Penguins |
| Mean Streits 2: Reloaded | 208 | Devan Dubnyk | G | Oilers |
| Rat Portage Thistles | 209 | Andy Greene | D | Devils |
| Lady Bada Byng | 210 | Mike Knuble | F | Capitals |
| Laraque The Casbah | 211 | Jordan Leopold | D | Sabres |
| Chicken Parm | 212 | Patric Hornqvist | F | Predators |
| Eight Is Phaneuf | 213 | Dmitry Kulikov | D | Panthers |
| Czech Out Lines | 214 | Trevor Daley | D | Stars |
| Ice Age: Continental Draft | 215 | Matt Carkner | D | Senators |
| The Haves And The Havlats | 216 | Vaclav Prospal | F | Blue Jackets |
